By Lucca Vudor Australia · November 2026
In short: If a pair is unworn and still within the return window, sending it back for the right size is the cleanest fix. If you keep it, fill the extra space in the right place: a half insole when your toes slide forward, a heel grip when your heel lifts, a full insole when the whole shoe feels roomy. Shoes with a buckle, laces or an ankle strap are the easiest to wear when they are a little big, because you can tighten them.

My shoes are too big: what should I do first?
Before you add anything, check whether you can still return them. Wear new shoes only indoors, on carpet, for the first try, and keep the box. If the shoe is clearly a full size too long, an insert will not make it feel right for a whole day, and swapping for the right size is better. If it is only a little loose, the fixes below usually work.
How do I know if a shoe is too big?
Stand up with your weight on both feet and press just in front of your longest toe. About a finger’s width of space is normal. More than a thumb’s width means the shoe is long. Then walk across the room: if your heel lifts out at every step, your toes slide forward on a heel, or you grip with your toes to keep the shoe on, it is too big somewhere.
Shoes too big: how to fix them
- Toes slide forward: a half insole or ball-of-foot pad under the front of the foot stops the slide, which matters most in heels.
- Heel slips out at the back: a heel grip stuck inside the back of the shoe fills the gap. Our guide to shoes slipping off your heel has more on this.
- The whole shoe feels loose: a thin full-length insole takes up volume everywhere. Try it in the shoe before you trim it to size.
- Loose over the top of the foot: a tongue pad, stuck under the tongue of a lace-up or loafer, presses your foot back into the heel.
- Thicker socks: simple for loafers, brogues and boots in winter; less useful for heels and sandals.
- A shoe repairer: many can add an elastic or a strap to a court shoe, or punch an extra hole in a buckle strap.
Is half a size too big okay?
Usually, yes. Half a size is only a few millimetres of length, which a half insole or a heel grip takes up well. Half a size too small is harder to live with, because you cannot add space to a shoe. That is why, if you are between sizes, it is safer to take the next size up and fill the gap than to squeeze into the smaller one.
Heels too big in the back: what is the quick fix?
A heel grip is the quickest. If your foot also slides forward and your toes press into the front, add a half insole as well, so the foot sits back in the heel cup. Avoid stuffing tissue into the toe of a heel: it shifts as you walk and pushes the problem around rather than fixing it.
Which shoes are easiest when they run a little big?
Anything you can tighten. A lace-up can be pulled in, a buckle strap moves a hole, and a slingback or ankle strap holds the heel in place. Slip-on court shoes and ballet flats have nothing to adjust, so they need the closest fit of all.
Pairs you can adjust
- Fenella: a laced wingtip brogue in burnished leather.
- Hecuba: a pointed d’Orsay Mary Jane with a buckled instep strap.
- Hortensia: a caged pointed slingback with fine leather straps across the foot.
- Sesa: an open-toe block-heel sandal with an ankle strap.
- Farida: a square-toe Mary Jane ballet flat with an elastic strap across the instep.
Our shoes come in whole EU sizes, from 35 to 41 (AU 5 to 11) in most styles; check the EU to AU shoe size chart against your foot length before you order. Every pair is built on the Lucca Vudor Lambskin Support Insole, a cushioned footbed with a soft lining. You can return unworn pairs within 7 days of delivery for a full refund, so you can try your size at home.