By Lucca Vudor Australia · November 2026
In short: Shoes rub the back of the heel when the heel moves up and down against a firm back edge, or when that edge sits too high or too stiff for your foot. Stop the movement first (a heel grip, a half insole, or a tighter strap), then protect the spot (a blister plaster or a sock) while new shoes soften with short indoor wear. If one pair keeps rubbing no matter what, a style that is open at the back, such as a slingback or a mule, takes that edge away.

Why do my shoes rub the back of my heel?
Most of the time it is movement. If a shoe is a little long or loose, your heel lifts at every step and the back of the shoe rubs the same patch of skin hundreds of times a day. The other cause is shape: a stiff heel counter, or a back edge that sits higher than the soft dip below your ankle bone, presses into the skin even when the fit is right. New shoes do both more, because the leather has not softened yet.
How do I stop shoes rubbing the back of my heel?
Work out which cause it is, then use the matching fix.
- Heel lifts as you walk: stick a heel grip inside the back of the shoe to fill the gap. If your foot also slides forward, add a half insole under the ball of the foot so the heel sits back in place.
- Back edge digs in: a soft heel liner or a strip of moleskin on the edge itself softens the contact while the leather breaks in.
- A strap or buckle: tighten it one hole. Less movement means less rubbing.
- Protect the skin first: a blister plaster on the spot before you head out, or a thin sock or footlet with closed shoes, stops friction landing on bare skin.
- Soften the counter: wear the shoes at home with socks for 20 to 30 minutes at a time and gently flex the back with your hands between wears.
- A shoe repairer: many can stretch or soften a stiff heel counter, or add a padded lining to the back.
My new shoes rub my heels: will they stop?
Often, yes. Leather softens and moulds to your heel over a few short wears, and the edge stops catching. Break them in indoors, on carpet, so you can still return them if they never settle. If the shoe is clearly too big and your heel slips right out, a size swap is a better fix than padding. Our guide to shoes that are too big walks through the options.
Why do all my shoes rub my heels?
When every pair rubs, look at fit rather than the shoes. You may be buying half a size up, so each pair is slightly long, or your heels may be narrower than your forefoot, so most shoes are loose at the back. Measure your foot length in the afternoon and compare it with the size chart. Styles with a strap around the heel or ankle, or styles that leave the heel open, sidestep the problem.
Shoes rubbing the back of the ankle: what helps?
When the rub is higher up, on the ankle rather than the heel, the back edge is usually cut too high for you. Ankle boots and high-backed sneakers do this most. Fold a thin sock over the edge, try a heel liner, or choose a lower-cut style with the back edge sitting below the ankle bone.
When should I see someone?
If a blister breaks, looks red and hot, or the back of your heel hurts even in shoes that never rubbed before, see a podiatrist or your GP. Heel pain that stays after the rubbing stops is worth having checked.
Pairs open at the back
- Stelle: a pointed slingback kitten heel with a low tapered heel and a gold buckle.
- Sarina: a pointed leather slingback with a clean V-throat and a covered toe.
- Hebe: a pointed slingback on a stiletto heel, in smooth leather or a snake print.
- Saacha: a flat braided-leather slingback sandal with an open squared toe.
- Salynn: a backless mule with a loafer front and a gold-tone horsebit.
Every pair is built on the Lucca Vudor Lambskin Support Insole, a cushioned footbed with a soft lining. You can return unworn pairs within 7 days of delivery for a full refund, so try them at home, indoors, before you head out. For heels that lift out rather than rub, read shoes slipping off your heel.